Court Ruling Potentially Threatens Physicians' Immunity

Share this content:
Court Ruling Potentially Threatens Physicians' Immunity
Court Ruling Potentially Threatens Physicians' Immunity

FRIDAY, June 2, 2017 (HealthDay News) -- A court ruling allowing a civil rights lawsuit against a medical examiner may have serious consequences for physicians in public service, according to a report published by the American Medical Association.

The case involves a Texas medical examiner who compiled an autopsy report for a woman who had died from a gunshot wound, concluding that the woman had died from a homicide. After an initial trial of her former husband resulted in a hung jury, the charges were dropped during retrial when the medical examiner's office indicated that the cause of death was changed to undetermined following the medical examiner's cross-examination in court.

The husband sued the medical examiner for violation of his federal civil rights. The defendant moved for summary judgement, arguing that duties had been fulfilled in good faith and therefore led to entitlement of immunity. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas said that qualified immunity did not apply, allowing the plaintiff to proceed with the lawsuit. The defendant is asking the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans to overturn the federal court decision allowing the civil rights lawsuit to proceed. Several societies filed a friend-of-the-court brief asking the court to apply qualified immunity, noting their concern that the ruling will have a negative impact on forensic pathologists and other government-employed physicians.

"The district court's holding will have a chilling effect on medical examiners and other physicians who will, unable to reasonably anticipate what actions will subject them to liability, act to avert liability rather than act according to medical science and their patients' best interest," the friend-of-the-court brief states.

More Information

Share this content:

is free, fast, and customized just for you!

Already a member?

Sign In Now »


Sign up for myCME e-newsletters


Drug Lookup

Browse drugs by: BrandGenericDisease

Trending Activities

All Professions

More in Home

Even Overdose Doesn't Stop Opioid Prescribing

Even Overdose Doesn't Stop Opioid Prescribing

Few receive medication-assisted treatment after hospital discharge, researchers find

NT-ProBNP-Guided Treatment No Benefit in High-Risk HFrEF

NT-ProBNP-Guided Treatment No Benefit in High-Risk HFrEF

No improvement in clinical outcomes versus usual care in heart failure and reduced ejection fraction

Oral Corticosteroids No Benefit for LRI in Non-Asthmatic Adults

Oral Corticosteroids No Benefit for LRI in Non-Asthmatic ...

No decrease in cough duration, severity for adults without asthma with lower respiratory tract symptom

is free, fast, and customized just for you!

Already a member?

Sign In Now »